(Source: MIRS.news, Published 04/09/2024) The State Board of Education approved a resolution during its meeting Tuesday calling for legislation to open charter schools to be treated more like public schools in the state of Michigan.
Mitchell Robinson’sresolution made the agenda and asked the state Legislature to create and pass laws that would put charter schools under the approval of the Michigan Department of Education and make them more transparent by opening them up to the Freedom of Information Act and Open Meetings Act.
The resolution also asked for legislation that would require charter schools to follow many of the same requirements as public schools, such as bidding for vendors, requirements that no child be excluded from enrolling, not refusing transfer students if space is open, require teachers and administrators to hold certificates, and mandate contracts for management organizations be published online.
“So charter schools are technically public schools, so they should be expected to follow regulations regarding transparency, as all publicly funded schools are,” Robinson said.
However, he said many charter schools are dominated by politically-motivated special interest groups, those looking to be education reformers, and “predatory for-profit organizations.”
He said he’s looked at the charter school system in Michigan and found that they make up one-third of all the local education agencies in the state and are not accountable to the communities.
“I see no evidence of innovation in this service sector,” he said.
He said the public school system struggles to adequately fund itself, not even adding the charter system that also pulls funding for the 363 schools across 285 districts.
“This is financially irresponsible,” he said.
The sole no vote against the resolution came from Tom McMillin, a Republican board member.
He argued that charter schools fill in gaps in education and were already fully transparent with the public funding they received.
“These charter schools give parents choices. They fill up for a reason,” McMillin said.
He said the teachers and administrators were already required to be certified.
“What this would do is simply force charter schools to not open, which is what some people want,” McMillin said.
Marshall Bullock II pointed to troubles with charter schools in the Detroit area closing without warning or opening in a struggling district that could have the “unintended consequence” of splitting a neighborhood.
“That is how you destroy a neighborhood,” Bullock said.
McMillin called it “perverse” to not give parents a choice and “force them, based on their zip code, to a failing school.” He placed the problem at the feet of the state superintendent.
Tiffany Tilley asked that the board hear a presentation to look at what other states are doing in terms of charter schools.
“Michigan has become kind of like the Wild Wild West when it comes to charter schools,” Tilley said.
She said you can’t have “thousands” of charter schools with no transparency and continue to maintain a well-funded system, but putting a limit on the number of charters schools could help.
“We do need to change the laws and this has gone on for a very long time,” she said.
